Above: composer Huw Watkins; photo by B Ealovega
~ Author: Oberon
Friday February 22nd, 2019 – The US premiere of Huw Watkins‘ Quintet for Piano, Two Violins, Viola, and Cello was the centerpiece of this evening’s Chamber Music Society of Lincoln Center concert at Alice Tully Hall. The evening further afforded an all-too-rare chance to hear some Khachaturian. As always, the Society drew together a formidable ensemble of musicians, including some particular favorites of mine.
Unfortunately, my enjoyment of the performance was seriously compromised by the thoughtless behavior of some audience members who were seated (late) in my immediate area. The opening Debussy sonata – excellently played – was thoroughly to my liking: I felt relaxed amid a crowd of eagerly attentive music lovers. Then the intruders arrived: after having my foot stepped on and being hit in the face by a large pocketbook, I tried to re-connect to the music – the much-anticipated Khachaturian – but these new arrivals took time settling in. Soon we had eating, drinking, texting, and picture-taking going on…to say nothing of someone with a noisy runny nose. It took all my powers of concentration to make it thru the fascinating Watkins, after which I headed home rather than trying to focus – against the odds – on the Brahms sextet that closed the evening.
Opening a program entitled ‘International Collection‘, France was represented by Claude Debussy’s Sonata for Cello and Piano (1915), a brief work in three movements. Cellist Paul Watkins and pianist Gilles Vonsattel brought us this music in a polished performance that evoked ardent applause, calling the two men back to the stage for a bow.
The sonata begins with Prologue, which commences with a piano solo. The music veers from animated to pensive; it builds and then becalms. Mr. Watkins’ handsome cello sound made a particularly fine impression in a descending passage where the resonance took on an inviting richness. This leads to a deep, poignant melody. Prologue fades gently away.
Mssrs. Watkins and Vonsattel then commence the witty Serenade, which has an almost sneaky feel to it. Some rather ironic cello plucking leads to a dance, which slows as Mr. Watkins provides some beautifully sustained notes. The Serenade flows directly into the Finale, which rolls along, alternately animated and somewhat thoughtful, to a quirky finish.
Now the latecomers were shown in; I looked around to see if there might be a seat I could move to, away from them. But there wasn’t.
Aram Khachaturian’s Trio for Clarinet, Violin, and Piano (1932) was played by the inimitable David Shifrin, joined by violinist Paul Huang and Mr. Vonsattel. This three-part work opens with an Andante of melancholy mood. Mr. Huang is soon un-spooling his trademark silken tone, to ravishing effect in its high range, whilst Mr. Shifrin’s colourful sound brings a folkish feeling to his swirling roulades. From the Steinway, Mr. Vonsattel provides impeccable turns of phrase. The music fades into air.
The vari-tempo range of the second movement commences with a sense of mystery and allure; sheer gorgeousness flows from Mr. Huang’s violin. Then things speed up with a peasant dance, which slows to provide a finely-blended mix from the three voices. The movement has an unusual ending.
Mr. Shifrin opens the concluding Moderato with a marvelously-hued solo, and then Mr. Vonsattel shines in his own solo passage. The mood turns jaunty, with the clarinet sounding sustained phrases as the violin comments; then they switch roles. Another piano solo takes us to a final dance, which slows and then begins to break down, as though the players have decided it’s time to pause for a drink.
The Watkins work came next: his Quintet for Piano, Two Violins, Viola, and Cello is a CMS co-commission, composed in 2017 and having its US premiere tonight. The composer could not have asked for a finer collective of musicians to advocate for him: Paul Huang and Alexander Sitkovetsky (violins), Richard O’Neill (viola) and the composer’s brother, Paul Watkins (cello).
The Quintet’s opening Allegro molto kicks off with a fun, jazzy passage; soon, though, the music turns poetic, with a sense of longing. The strings blend marvelously over rapturous piano figurations. As the music becomes more animated, Mr. Huang’s violin soars: he plays over rippling motifs from Mr. Vonsattel’s keyboard while the other strings mesh in dense, highish passages. Outstanding was a poignant ‘chorale’ for the strings as the piano held onto a simple line…so wonderful to hear. Growing in intensity, the music becomes impassioned; then Richard O’Neill’s moonlit viola sings a sad passage. Things settle into a hesitant calm as the movement draws to a close.
By this point I am thoroughly intrigued; but there is still more to fascinate us ahead. The Lento opens with a sadly sweet violin theme radiating over teardrop notes from the piano. Paul Watkins’ cello joins, and sustained harmonies rise up from the collective. The O’Neill viola produces ‘shining music’, creating a haunting atmosphere. A sublime blending of timbres makes us want to linger, but we return to the movement’s opening violin/piano duo, so expressively played by Mssrs. Huang and Vonsattel. Briefly the music turns grand, only to shade away into delicacy. Paul Watkins takes up a poignant cello theme. The piano’s ‘teardrop’ motif recurs, now with Mr. Huang carrying our spirits to the heights with his serene playing. A long, long unison note from the strings is sustained as a hush settles over the hall.
Springlike music fills the air, with the piano shimmering, as the concluding Allegro vivace commences. Rising strings herald an increase in animation…and passion. Calming a bit, we hear Mr. Huang and his fellow violinist Alexander Sitkovetsky duetting whilst the viola and cello take a more settled stance. The music then erupts in a joyous tempest of sound to bring the Quintet to its close.
As applause resounded, the composer walked out onto the stage, thinking the musicians were right behind him; instead, they held back, leaving Huw Watkins to have a solo curtain call. The players then joined him, to enjoy the waves of approbation filling the house. They all left, but the audience – everyone standing – insisted on a much-merited second bow.
In an age when so much ‘new’ music is expertly-crafted but fails to evoke an emotional response, Huw Watkins’ new Piano Quintet felt like a breath of fresh air.
I was sorry to forego hearing tonight’s excellent group of string players in the Johannes Brahms’ Sextet No. 2, but enough is enough: it’s the triumph of indifference, yet again, as people who don’t care spoil things for people who do.
~ Oberon





































