Above: Ralph Vaughan Williams
Author: Oberon
Friday April 21st, 2023 – The Choral Society and Orchestra of Grace Church presenting a performance of Ralph Vaughan Williams’s A SEA SYMPHONY, conducted by John Maclay, with soloists Tami Petty (soprano) and Hadleigh Adams (baritone).
Vaughan Williams selected for the first three movements of A SEA SYMPHONY three poems from Walt Whitman’s Leaves of Grass. The symphony’s first two movements are entitled “A Song for All Seas, All Men” and “On the Beach at Night Alone.” The third movement, called in the symphony “The Waves“, is Whitman’s poem in the same series entitled “After the Sea Ship.” For the fourth and longest movement, entitled “The Explorers“, the composer chose lines from widely scattered excerpts of another lengthy sub-section of Leaves of Grass entitled “Passage to India.”
In all four movements, the composer tightened up the poetry to best serve his musical vision of the boundless sea. From the first brass fanfare proclaiming the words “Behold the Sea!” to the mystical choral invocation of a “…vast rondure, swimming in space“, words and music align to depict both the epic grandeur and the meditative power of the planet’s oceans.
This evening was very frustrating for me, as I have waited years to hear this work performed live. The audience included many people who brought small children, and of course, two such youngsters were seated directly in front of us. After being reasonably well behaved during the first movement, they became fidgety and restless. The parents basically ignored their antics, especially during the long final movement. My companion and I were exasperated by the situation: yet another case of the triumph of people who don’t care over people who do.
Musically, the evening got off to an uneven start. The balance between the orchestra, the huge chorus, and the soloists was off; the blend became mushy and most of the words were incomprehensible. The symphony’s great opening movement therefore went for nought. Things improved greatly during the second and most haunting movement, “On the Beach at Night Alone” and the ensuing scherzo, “The Waves“, was well done. In the over-long final movement, the composer seems to have been unable to decide how to end the piece: he would periodically venture into a cul de sac, delaying the inevitable.
The evening’s soloists are both possessed of fine voices. Baritone Hadleigh Adams was sometimes overwhelmed by the orchestra in the opening movement, but that is the conductor’s fault. Mr. Adams came into his own with a wonderful rendering of “On the Beach at Night Alone” where his expressive singing and fine timbre could be deeply enjoyed. An eloquent passage for solo cello enhanced the singing, making this the highlight of the evening.
Soprano Tami Petty has a clear, sweet voice that blooms as it ascends; in this regard, she reminded me of Helena Dix, the Australian soprano who sang Norma at The Met earlier this year. Ms. Petty sounded truly lovely in the big Hall, making me hope she’ll have a go at the Verdi REQUIEM here someday soon.
Above, bowing during the massive standing ovation at the concert’s end, are Ms. Petty, Maestro Maclay, and Mr. Adams; photo by Brian Hatton.
I don’t anticipate another opportunity to hear A SEA SYMPHONY here in New York City again in my lifetime, but I have the marvelous Grammy Award-winning Telarc CD of it with the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra and Chorus, conducted by Robert Spano, and wonderful soloists Christine Goerke and Brett Polegato that I can turn to.
~ Oberon
Oberon's Glade 